I wanted to continue from where we left off two posts ago, by talking about the value of public online trees as a form of hint. But before getting into that it seemed sensible to start by thinking about your own online tree. Should it be public or private? What are the issues? How do you change these settings?
Public or private?
When you create your online tree on a subscription genealogy website like Ancestry or FindMyPast, you’ll be asked if you want it to be public or private. If it’s private only you, plus anyone you specifically invite, can see it. If it’s public anyone can see it. There are pros and cons for each. Some people prefer private for security reasons, some because they include treasured family photos and they don’t want these to be mis-used (e.g. applied to the wrong person in another tree). Others feel more comfortable with private if this particular tree is being used to work on a hypothesis and is as yet unproven. Yet others may not wish to be seen by another branch of the family with whom there has been a rift. With a public tree, on the other hand, you can share freely what you find with distant cousins; and there’s more chance of being contacted by others researching branches of your family. Whatever you decide, and whatever your own reasons for having your tree public or private, that will be the right decision for you.
If you’ve already set your tree up and want to check or amend these settings, it’s not too late. On Ancestry and FindMyPast you can change it as follows. (If you use a different site there will probably be similar options.)
Click on Trees (upper left corner of screen), then, if you have more than one tree, select the one for which you want to change the settings. When that opens, click again on the name of the tree (upper left corner on this screen), and select Tree Settings from the menu. Privacy Settings.is the middle option of the links in the upper middle of the next screen.
Click on Family Trees (upper left corner of screen), then on the tree for which you want to change the settings. When that opens, click on Tree Settings (the cog, upper right of screen). A new screen appears and amongst other things you can choose here to make the tree public or not.
Privacy for living people
Even if your tree is public, there are particular privacy issues for living people. I take privacy seriously, and I don’t know about you but I’d be pretty cross if I found myself and my family, with all names, places and dates of birth on a public tree for absolutely anyone to see.
On Ancestry, any person you mark as ‘living’ will remain private to others viewing your tree. In ‘tree view’ they will show up as an individual in the correct place in your family, but instead of a name with dates, the word ‘Private’ is shown, and the profile page for that person is not accessible. If you invite someone else to view your private tree, you can decide whether or not to allow them to see living people.
On FindMyPast you can choose whether living people should be visible or not. The settings for this are on the same page as the private tree settings, as outlined above.
One huge family tree for the world?
Some genealogy websites have a different approach to online trees. FamilySearch is all about helping others and working together to create a huge, communal family tree for the world. This is all very lovely,and I’m all for finding connections and ways to bring the world together. But different people have different approaches to genealogy. Everything on my tree is properly sourced and cross-referenced or is marked as a hypothesis – something I’m trying to prove or disprove. That’s not, of course, to say I don’t make mistakes, but if I do get something wrong, I can go back to where my original ‘evidence’ falls down, to put it right. Not everyone is so fastidious. Not everyone even attaches records, or if they do they may not look at the records, to gather all the available information from them and ensure that what follows is consistent. And yet on FamilySearch, anyone would have the authority and ability to come along and change my tree, without even consulting me. FamilySearch is a wonderful and generous site as far as records are concerned, but if you’re planning on putting your online tree on there you need to be aware of this.
I’m getting hot under the collar even as I type this, so for balance I found a video on YouTube about a more Zen approach to people messing up your tree…. 😊
It’s up to you to decide if this would work for you.
So, next time we’ll talk about using online public trees to develop your own tree.